Additive vs Subtractive Manufacturing: Understanding the Differences

Additive Manufacturing vs Subtractive Manufacturing

In the ever-evolving world of manufacturing, understanding the differences between additive and subtractive manufacturing methods can be crucial for selecting the right approach for your projects. Both methods offer unique benefits and cater to different needs, making them valuable tools in industrial and embedded computing applications. Here’s a comprehensive look at both methods to help you make an informed decision.

Additive Manufacturing: Innovation at Its Finest

Additive manufacturing (AM), commonly known as 3D printing is a cutting-edge approach to creating parts and products. This technique builds objects layer by layer directly from a digital model, offering a range of materials such as plastics, metals, ceramics and composites.

Advantages of Additive Manufacturing:

• Complex Geometries: Capable of creating intricate and complex designs.
• Material Efficiency: Minimizes waste by using only the material needed.
• Customization: Ideal for rapid prototyping and custom parts.

Disadvantages of Additive Manufacturing:

• Speed: Generally slower for large-scale production.
• Surface Finish: May require post-processing for a smooth finish.
• Material Limitations: Limited range of high-performance materials.
• Size Constraints: Limited by the build volume of the printer.
• Cost for Large Volumes: Less cost-effective for mass production

Additive Manufacturing Machines

• Fused Deposition Modelling (FDM) Printers
• Stereolithography (SLA) Printers
• Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) Printers
• Digital Light Processing (DLP) Printers
• Electron Beam Melting (EBM) Machines

Applications: Additive manufacturing is highly beneficial for industries requiring detailed prototypes, custom parts, and innovative designs. It’s widely used in sectors like aerospace, automotive, healthcare, and consumer goods.

Subtractive Manufacturing: Precision and Speed

Subtractive manufacturing (SM) involves carving out the desired shape from a solid block or sheet of material. This method includes techniques such as machining, grinding, and drilling and is renowned for its precision and speed.

Advantages of Subtractive Manufacturing:

• Precision and Surface Finish: Provides high accuracy and a smooth surface finish.
• Speed: Often faster for producing large quantities.
• Established Technology: Well-established with a range of machines and tools.

Disadvantages of Subtractive Manufacturing:

• Material Waste: Can result in significant waste from cutting away material.
• Complexity Limitations: Less capable of producing complex geometries.
• Setup and Tooling Costs: High initial costs for setup and tooling.
• Production Time for Complex Parts: Can be longer for complex parts.
• Design Flexibility: Changes can be costly and time-consuming.

Subtractive Manufacturing Machines

• CNC Milling Machines
• CNC Lathes
• Drilling Machines
• Grinding Machines
• Wire Electrical Discharge Machines (EDM)

Applications: Subtractive manufacturing is commonly used for producing high-precision metal parts, components for machinery, and products requiring a fine surface finish. It is prevalent in industries such as automotive, defence, and industrial machinery.

Making the Right Choice for Your Project

Choosing between additive and subtractive manufacturing depends on your specific needs, including the complexity of the part, material requirements, production volume and desired finish. Each method has its strengths and is best suited to particular applications.

Example: Manufacturing an Aluminium Chassis for a Rugged Computer

• Additive Manufacturing: Using 3D printing to create an aluminium chassis can be time-consuming. While it allows for intricate designs, the slow build time may not be ideal for large or urgent production runs. Additionally, the size constraints of most 3D printers could limit the chassis dimensions or require assembly of multiple parts.
• Subtractive Manufacturing: CNC machining the chassis from a solid aluminium block is significantly faster and more efficient for large production volumes. However, this method generates a substantial amount of waste material. For example, if an aluminium block costs £1000 and 70% of it is wasted during machining, the cost of the wasted material would be approximately £700. While CNC machining achieves high precision and a good surface finish, the environmental and cost implications of material waste are notable factors to consider.

Choosing the right method depends on balancing factors like speed, cost, material efficiency, and the specific requirements of your project.

View Now >

View Now >

View Now >

Contact Us for Expert Guidance

Whether you’re exploring the best manufacturing approach for your next project or need bespoke solutions, BVM is here to help. With over 35 years of experience in supplying Industrial and Embedded Computer hardware, our expert sales team can provide the support and solutions you need.

Contact us today at 01489 780144 or email us at sales@bvmltd.co.uk. If an off-the-shelf solution isn’t available, our in-house design team is ready to create a custom solution tailored to your requirements. Trust BVM for all your industrial and embedded computing needs!

Design | Develop | Test | Manufacture

Here’s a selection of our design, manufacturing & associated services: –

.

Design to Order: OEM/ODM Embedded Product Design Services

For customers designing a brand-new product from scratch
or working with an existing prototype.

• Industrial and Embedded PC Design and Manufacturing
  • Custom Panel PCs and HMIs
  • Custom Racks, Towers and Mini-ITX Computers
  • Rugged, Portable Peli Case PCs
• Prototyping
  • Rapid Prototyping: 3D Printed Cost-Effective Prototypes
  • Multiple prototype versions, different design variations and flexible design capabilities
• Prototyping pre checks
  • Hardware and Software compatibility
  • Thermal and Environmental testing
• Custom PCB / Carrier Board Design
  • COM Express, Qseven, SMARC, Jetson, Raspberry Pi
• Custom Chassis Design
  • Metal and Plastic
• Custom Cables, Custom Cooling and Custom Power Supplies
• Custom Back Panels and Faceplates
• Custom Metal Work (internal brackets, mounting brackets)
• Touchscreen Integration and Display Enhancements
  • Custom LCD Displays: 7″ – 21″
  • Integration of PCAP and Resistive touch technologies
  • Optical Bonding, Anti-reflective and Anti-glare coatings
• All products are Designed for Manufacture

.

Build to Order: System Integration and Customisation Services​

Take an existing system and we can:

• Custom hardware specifications
  • (CPU, RAM, I/O, Industrial-Grade Storage, RAID)
• Chassis Customisation and Branding
• Custom BIOS
• Long Term Availability (5+ years)
• Software – Custom OS Image
• Custom Packaging and branding
• Integrating newly designed or existing hardware into a larger system

Build to order Racks and Towers, Peli Case PCs and Mini-ITX PCs

Embedded Software Services

Porting, Integration & Deployment

• Windows image capture from customers HDD
• Linux and Android image capture from customers HDD
• Windows/Linux/Android Deployment from customers image
• Custom Windows images, create and deploy
• Custom Linux and Android images
• Update management
• Custom BIOS

.